How Do I Know if I Need a New Roof?

Brunette Home Improvement • February 16, 2026
How Do I Know if I Need a New Roof?

When it comes to replacing your roof, there are so many small signs that can show your roof’s age that many people end up missing them. Just having one of these small issues does not mean that you must replace your roof right away, but it is a sign that the time is coming. Some of these signs may be glaringly obvious, while others may be hidden, so it is always advisable to have a professional inspect your roof so that you know exactly what needs to be done.


Let’s dive into the most common causes of roof replacement, and what causes these issues to begin with:

Close-up of a weathered gray shingled roof on a steep slope, with leafless trees in the background

Granule Loss

Asphalt shingles have been the go-to roofing material for years. Asphalt shingles are equipped with a granule surface that is made up of crushed rock. These granules are not a permanent fixture and can be lost due to many different circumstances, including:


  • Normal aging: This natural cause of granule loss will occur as your roof gets older. As it gets closer to its maximum age range, you will start to notice granules in your gutters and bare spots on your shingles. In an ideal world, this won’t occur until your roof has
  • Hail damage: Many areas of the United States have been plagued with large hail that has proven to be detrimental to roofs. Hail can cause severe damage by pitting the shingles and causing damage to the granules. reached its maximum longevity, but that is not always the case
  • Adverse weather: Almost any kind of unfavorable weather has the capability of damaging your roof. Wind can lift and detach shingles, rain and snow can cause water damage, and extreme heat can age your roof faster than cooler climates.

Curling Shingles

Something that most people notice as the first sign that their roof needs to be replaced is when shingles start to lift and curl. There are many causes to this occurrence, including:


  • The end of lifespan: This is pretty self-explanatory. Shingles have a set lifespan, and when your roof starts getting closer to the end of this lifespan, the shingles will start to show signs of needing to be replaced, like lifting and curling.
  • Ventilation: Proper roof ventilation allows the intake and outtake of air in your attic, keeping shingles at a desirable temperature. If you do not have the right ventilation installed, then moist air can get trapped in your attic, trapping heat beneath the shingles causing them to start warping.
  • Installing new shingles over old ones: Although this is a fairly common practice, it is not ideal for the longevity of your new shingles. Installing new shingles over old ones can prevent the new ones from sealing properly, resulting in the possibility of them lifting and curling faster than properly installed shingles.
Gray shingled roof viewed from below, with rows of overlapping asphalt shingles.
Close-up of a brick wall corner with white sealant along the base beside dark paving stones.

Leaky Pipe Boots, Roof Vents and Chimneys

A pipe boot is a type of flashing that is used around pipes that exit through the roof. Over time these fixtures can start decaying, allowing water to enter through the roof around these pipes.  Also check your roof vents and chimneys for leaking.

Seeing Sunlight in Your Attic

If you go up into your attic and are able to see sunlight peeking through your roof boards, then it is probably time to replace your roof. As the shingles age and maybe even start to curl and fall off, you may be able to see a little light through the roof boards. At this point of deterioration, it is time to have a professional come in to inspect your roof.

Roof vent pipe with a white flashing base on brown shingles, showing rust and weathering
Close-up of a gray shingled roof with white gutter and blue sky visible at the edge

Sagging Areas

As a roof ages and sustains some water damage, you may notice a spongy feel as you walk across it or in more extreme cases, you may even be able to see the effect of the sagging. This means that the underlying decking is weakened from moisture and needs to be replaced ASAP to avoid collapse.


Ultimately, there are many observable and invisible signs that your roof is coming up to the end of its useful lifespan. When you start seeing the obvious signs of decay, it is time to bring in a professional to take a look and tell you what your options are. In some cases, you may be able to repair the problem section of the roof, but in cases where there is moderate to severe damage or there are structural concerns, you need to replace the roof for the safety of those living in the home.


There are many options out there for your new roof, and we can help you pick out the right one for you, your home, and your lifestyle. Contact us at Brunette to talk about your options and to book your roof inspection. We will help you figure out what is right for you.

Recent Posts

By Brunette Home Improvement August 21, 2026
Ridge vents exhaust hot air and moisture along the roof peak in East Lansing, MI. Learn how balanced intake keeps your attic dry and energy costs lower year-round.
By Brunette Home Improvement August 18, 2026
Box vents offer spot exhaust for roofs in Okemos, MI where ridge vents aren't practical. Discover pros, limitations, and how they compare visually and functionally.
transparent
By Brunette Home Improvement August 1, 2026
Enhance your DeWitt home with expert siding installation. Choose from durable vinyl & fiber cement options. Contact us for a consultation!
By Brunette Home Improvement July 22, 2026
Pipe boots seal plumbing vents and roof penetrations in DeWitt, MI. Discover how proper integration prevents leaks and the warning signs to watch for around pipes.
By Brunette Home Improvement July 22, 2026
Chimney flashing in Grand Ledge, MI uses base and counter layers to prevent leaks. Learn why tar fails, how masonry shifts, and the role of chimney caps.
By Brunette Home Improvement July 22, 2026
Step flashing directs water away from roof-to-wall joints in Lansing, MI. Learn where it's used, how it integrates with shingles, and common leak causes.
transparent
By Brunette Home Improvement July 1, 2026
Get premium window installation to enhance energy efficiency & curb appeal. Contact us for expert solutions today!
transparent
By Brunette Home Improvement June 1, 2026
Transform your outdoor space with custom deck installation. Contact us for expert design & installation services today!
transparent
By Brunette Home Improvement June 1, 2026
Enhance your home with expert additions & remodeling. Improve comfort & value with our professional services. Contact us for a consultation!
transparent
By Brunette Home Improvement June 1, 2026
Get fast storm damage repairs & restoration. Our experts handle roofing, siding, & windows. Contact us for help today!
Show More