What to look for in a roofing proposal

Brunette Home Improvement • February 16, 2026
What to look for in a roofing proposal

Even though every roof is different, you want to make sure the main items are clearly stated in the proposal so that you know what you are getting. Here is a list of common standards in a professional roofing proposal.


Tear off or shingle over?

You want to make sure the contractor clearly states if they are going over the existing shingles or completely removing all existing layers (there could be multiple!). Here in Lansing, the maximum amount of shingle layers allowed on a roof is two.


Decking replacement

You never know what surprises lurk under a roof’s shingles, so you always want to have provisions in place for if you run into damaged decking. Make sure clear and precise actions are specified in the contract for however much decking is replaced.


Learn more here: Wood Repair & Decking Replacement


Crickets and saddles

When the roof is torn off, it’s the perfect time to build any new crickets or saddles that are needed. Whether you have a chimney that is causing leaks or a dead valley that is not draining water, make sure you get them handled at that time.


Roof underlayment

There are all sorts of roofing underlayments out there, and each one serves a different purpose. Make sure that the right type for you is stated clearly in the proposal.


Shingle flashings

A new shingle is useless unless it’s flashed appropriately. When replacing a roof, it is important to have the old flashings replaced with new. Make sure the proposal states where old flashings are being replaced with new.


Shingle manufacturer and series

Never allow a contractor to put “dimensional shingle” or “architectural style shingle” on your contract. With those types of vague statements, you could literally get something from the bargain bin at the local box store. Make sure that the shingle brand and series is clearly stated. For example: “CertainTeed – Landmark” shingles. CertainTeed is the manufacturer and Landmark is the series.


Roof ventilation

In order to ensure the longevity of your roofing investment, make sure that your contractor addresses any ventilation concerns you have in the proposal. There are many different types of ventilation systems for different type of applications. Always make sure to know which roof ventilation system is right for you.


Material and workmanship warranties

Typically the shingle warranty is covered by the manufacturer, but the workmanship is almost always covered by the installer. Make sure that the warranties are clearly stated in the proposal so you know who to contact if there are any issues once the project is completed.


Cost and payment structure

Once you are comfortable with all the other aspects of the proposal, it’s time to go over the numbers. Replacing your roof is a costly process and you don’t want to skimp when it comes to your home. You will want to have the cost clearly defined along with the provisions for any extras that may come up. Typically companies require a down payment to get started. Just make sure that the terms are written in a way that you fully understand them, and keep a record of any payments made along the way.

Recent Posts

By Brunette Home Improvement August 26, 2026
Michigan weather demands durable siding in Grand Ledge, MI. Discover materials and installation methods that resist wind, ice, and moisture year-round.
By Brunette Home Improvement August 26, 2026
Wind, hail, and heavy rain cause immediate roof damage in DeWitt, MI. Learn how emergency restoration services protect your home and assist with insurance claims.
By Brunette Home Improvement August 26, 2026
Michigan's freeze-thaw cycles cause shingle deterioration, ice dams, and roof leaks in Lansing, MI. Learn how to protect your home from seasonal damage.
By Brunette Home Improvement August 21, 2026
Ridge vents exhaust hot air and moisture along the roof peak in East Lansing, MI. Learn how balanced intake keeps your attic dry and energy costs lower year-round.
By Brunette Home Improvement August 18, 2026
Box vents offer spot exhaust for roofs in Okemos, MI where ridge vents aren't practical. Discover pros, limitations, and how they compare visually and functionally.
transparent
By Brunette Home Improvement August 1, 2026
Enhance your DeWitt home with expert siding installation. Choose from durable vinyl & fiber cement options. Contact us for a consultation!
By Brunette Home Improvement July 22, 2026
Pipe boots seal plumbing vents and roof penetrations in DeWitt, MI. Discover how proper integration prevents leaks and the warning signs to watch for around pipes.
By Brunette Home Improvement July 22, 2026
Chimney flashing in Grand Ledge, MI uses base and counter layers to prevent leaks. Learn why tar fails, how masonry shifts, and the role of chimney caps.
By Brunette Home Improvement July 22, 2026
Step flashing directs water away from roof-to-wall joints in Lansing, MI. Learn where it's used, how it integrates with shingles, and common leak causes.
transparent
By Brunette Home Improvement July 1, 2026
Get premium window installation to enhance energy efficiency & curb appeal. Contact us for expert solutions today!
Show More